How we score
How the Black Shield Score and the Field Reports on our product pages are put together.
What the Black Shield Score is
A Field Report is our own assessment of a product, informed by public feedback from people who own and use it. The Black Shield Score sums it up out of 10, with one decimal.
What goes into it
- Public feedback from owners, such as owner reviews on retail sites and discussions on enthusiast forums
- Longer-term tests that owners and testers have published
- The product's specs and materials
- The warranty
- The price against similar items
Sub-scores
Each report has two to four sub-scores from the set for its kind of product, and always includes the set's core (shown after each set):
- Optics and mounts: Clarity, Holds zero, Durability, Value (core: Holds zero or Durability)
- Triggers: Feel, Install & fit, Reliability, Value (core: Reliability or Install & fit)
- Lights and lasers: Output, Durability, Runtime, Value (core: Durability or Output)
- Magazines: Reliability, Fit, Durability, Value (core: Reliability or Fit)
- Everything else: Quality, Fit, Reliability, Value (core: Reliability or Fit)
Mounts without glass, like rings and bases, use the “everything else” set. Value is where the price against similar items and the warranty count. The other sub-scores come mainly from owner feedback, checked against the specs and materials. A sub-score without enough to go on is left out (most often Value), never guessed. The Black Shield Score is the plain average of the sub-scores it has, rounded to one decimal.
When there isn't enough to go on
We publish a score only when we've found enough independent owner feedback: at least three separate sources, from different sites and different authors, with at least one of them owner feedback, or a single retailer page where at least ten different owners have weighed in. Copies of the same content count once. Below that, the product page shows a dash and “Not yet rated” instead of a guess. If one or two owners have posted, we may still share a short summary of what they said, clearly marked as limited.
Who writes it
We gather and summarize public owner feedback and published tests, and we decide what counts and when there's enough to score before anything is published.
How we write it
- In our own words. We don't quote anyone, name our sources or link to them.
- Complaints sit next to the praise, under “Good to know”. We don't drop the negatives.
- We don't claim to have tested anything we haven't.
- We check again from time to time, and each report shows the month it was last checked.
What it isn't
A Field Report is not a customer review, and the Black Shield Score isn't an average of customer ratings. If we add customer reviews later, they'll be separate and clearly labeled.
Think a report is wrong?
Email support@blackshieldsupply.com with the product and what you think we got wrong. We'll look into it.